Effect of color coded information on students levels of. Some scholars feel, however, that the geft measures ability rather than learning style, making it an inappropriate choice as a tool to help students understand themselves. Field dependence had a main effect on the amount of belief in superstition across three different instructions. The relationship between field dependence independence cognitive style and use of vocabulary learning strategies among iranian female efi learners. This paper develops a framework for understanding the relationships between approaches to learning adopted by students in the context of higher education and the concept of field dependence field independence. Field dependenceindependence cognitive style and academic. Field dependenceindependence and computerbased instruction in geography judith k. You tend to rely on structure and on receiving direction. The enlightenment of cognitive style differences between. In general, people who exhibit field dependence tend to rely on information provided by the outer world, the field or frame of a situation and their cognition toward other things is based on this overall field. Other articles where field dependence is discussed. Cognitive style field dependence independence interaction interpersonal competence national institute of mental health personality abstract.
Over the long history of research on psychological differentiation, there have been continuous changes in the empirical picture, and, accompanying them. Hall abstract research on the cognitive style field dependenceindependence establishes its influence on learning and students outcomes across academic disciplines and at all levels of schooling. There was a significant relationship between field dependence field independence cognitive style and career choice of the students. This is one of the rare learning styles instruments that has been reasonably well validated. Finally, a distinction is drawn between people who are fixed with regard to the characteristics associated with a field. An effect of the different instructions suggesting that paranormal phenomena are scientifically proven unproven or an interaction between instructions and cognitive style of the subjects could not be found.
A study conducted by antonietti and gioletta 1995 found that males were more analogical problem solvers than the females. Field dependence, suggestibility and belief in paranormal. Summary of studies measuring relationship between field dependence and extraversion field dependence extraversion p author date measure measure sex n r 2tails notes esans 1967 eft and dap mpi m 411 f 19 0. The more fieldindependent people are, the greater is their ability to articulate a field. The sample consisted of 170 volunteers who were vocational education teachers and trainers in the process of completing the requirements for either a diploma or a bachelors degree at a university in. Many experimental studies have shown the impact of field dependence and field independence on the learning. Fielddependence and fieldindependence xichen,1,2 shenzhao,1,2 andweili 1,2. Age there appears to be some effect of age on field dependenceindependence.
So an over simplification would be that fielddependence leads to popularity and fieldindependence leads to academic success. Part of thebilingual, multilingual, and multicultural education commons,english language. He tested english language ability and cognitive styles i. Field dependenceindependence and computerbased instruction. Our ability to give every child a chance to succeed in school d epends upon a full. This process, over a range of given visual fields, enables the measurement of. Field dependencefield independence cognitive style. Fielddependentfieldindependent rewired for technology. The study posits that while in the short term there is a positive benefit of a match between teacher and learner field dependence field independence, learning styles may be able to be modified. Pdf the difference between fielddependent versus field. Field dependence and independence in english as a second language esl. File scanned at 300 ppi monochrome, 24bit color using capture perfect 3. Field dependence independence was the earliest studied area in the study of cognitive styles. Field dependenceindependence as a cognitive style the model presented has implications for both the conception of cognitive styles and for use of the designation field dependenceindependence.
The interaction between field dependent independent. Field dependent learners generally perform less well than field. Field dependence independence and computerbased instruction in geography judith k. Fielddependent learners teachingenglish british council. Pdf adaptive teaching and field dependenceindependence. The field dependenceindependence cognitive style does not. Fieldindependent learners tend to rely less on the teacher or other learners for support. In the classroom activities such as extensive reading and writing, which learners can carry out alone, are useful for field independent learners. Fielddependenceindependence cognitive style and performance. Afterwards, the strategy inventory for language learning sill. Show a rational, intrinsic appeal for the task withoutconsulting others. For example, learners can discuss what they know about a. There is a considerable body of knowledge that has been accumulated on cognitive style through empirical research chinien, 1990, and various cognitive style dimensions have been identified.
Field dependenceindependence, impulsivityreflectivity. This process, over a range of given visual fields, enables the measurement of the bipolar construct field dependencefield independence. Cognitive styles are among the dimensions of individual differences considered particularly relevant in adaptive teaching. People with a field dependent or field independent cognitive style are different in their interpersonal behavior in ways predicted from the theory of psychological differentiation. A field dependenceindependence factor was reported in his later book, psychological differentiation.
Typically like competition and individual recognition. The findings of this study indicated that field independence had a significant positive correlation with reflectivity, and field dependence also had a significant positive correlation with impulsivity. Based on these findings, appropriate recommendations were made. Possible causal connections among field dependence. Thirtyone field dependent 12 male, 19 female subjects and 35 field independent 21 male, 14 female subjects had the distance between themselves and a male or female confederate of the experimenter measured on an interpersonal distance mat. Pdf field dependence and independence in english as a. If i gave you a list of behaviors a person tended to engage in, based on the list on page 311, you should be able to identify that person as likely field independent or field dependent.
This pattern suggests that, with regard to value judgments, the field dependenceindependence dimension is bipolar. Do best with learning the history or theory of the activitybefore attempting to do the assignment analyticallearners. Introduction over the last decade the number of studies concerning the effects of learner traits such as field dependence independence cognitive style has increased considerably. In the classroom activities that connect different parts of a lesson are useful for fielddependent learners. Fielddependent and fieldindependent cognitive styles and. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Learning styles imagine you have just arrived in a foreign country whose language you neither speak nor read. In the classroom activities that connect different parts of a lesson are useful for field dependent learners.
Independence cognitive style on deductiveinductive grammar. European american students as a whole how are field independent learners characterized. In most public opinion dynamics models, people only consider that individuals update their opinions through interactions with other individuals. All other statements indicate field dependent preference. This study investigates relationships among conservation, field dependenceindependence, school variables, achievement, screening measures, sex and race. Later, witkin and his group developed an embedded figure test and did. Field dependencefield independence and vocational teachers. There was a significant relationship between field dependencefield independence cognitive style and career choice of the students. You are at the airport and your contact person is not there to meet you. Hall abstract research on the cognitive style field dependence independence establishes its influence on learning and students outcomes across academic disciplines and at all levels of schooling. Two major factors that may relate with field dependencefield independence cognitive style are gender and career choice.
Then, two groups of fielddependent and fieldindependent learners each consisting 65 learners were chosen after administering the group embedded figures test geft. A study used the standardized group embedded figures test to assess field dependencefield independence among groups of vocational education teachers of varied ages and teaching backgrounds. Paeth, ca a likert scaling of student value statements, field independencefield dependence, and experimentally induced change dissertation abstracts international 1973 34 2288b 2289b doctoral dissertation, oregon state university, 1973university microfilms no. Field dependenceindependence is one of the most heuristic cognitive style constructs and has been shown consistently to determine academic results of students, regardless of their educational level or cultural origin and the area of knowledge considered. The results indicated that a more of the koreans 72.
The relationship between field dependenceindependence cognitive style and use of vocabulary learning strategies among iranian female efi learners. Field independent learners appear to be more adept to the unstructured classroom than their field dependent counterparts. Hence, males tended towards field independence while the females tended towards field dependence. This has perhaps been largely due to a rather widespread acceptance of witkins concept of neutrality, i.
This study investigates relationships among conservation, field dependence independence, school variables, achievement, screening measures, sex and race. This paper develops a framework for understanding the relationships between approaches to learning adopted by students in the context of higher education and the concept of field dependencefield independence. Researcharticle opinion dynamics model based on cognitive styles. Field dependencefield dependence, cognitive style, gender, career choice, geft, ambiverts, science and arts. Field dependence revisited witkin 1977 ets research. Summary of studies measuring relationship between fielddependence and extraversion fielddependence extraversion p author date measure measure sex n r 2tails notes esans 1967 eft and dap mpi m 411 f 19 0. Field dependence fd refers to a cognitive style in which an individual tends to look at the whole of a learning task that contains many items.
The field independent cognitive style is ignored in such cases. Oct 10, 2014 field dependent and field independent. Mar 05, 2018 a field dependence independence factor was reported in his later book, psychological differentiation. A likert scaling of student value statements, field. Field dependence \ independence, cognitive style and deductiveinductive teaching. On the other hand, field independent people have greater skill in cognitive analysis and structuring. Age there appears to be some effect of age on field dependence independence. Later, witkin and his group developed an embedded figure test and did more work with human. Information and translations of field dependenceindependence in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. Motivated by impersonal, analytical activities that do notnecessitate a grouptype approach. Field independent persons spend more on self and seem readily to learn material that has a social context. This represents the field dependent cognitive style of the individual.
This represents the fielddependent cognitive style of the individual. These people are susceptible to deceptive cues when identifying known e. Therefore, it may be more advantageous to learners to experience both field dependent and field independent teachers and thereby learn to become more. It pertains to the extent to which people are influenced by inner fieldindependent or environmental fielddependent cues in orienting themselves in space and the extent to which they make fine differentiations in the. Field independent learners tend to rely less on the teacher or other learners for support. The practical application of the knowledge gained from the concept of field dependence independence is important for all nurses because information processing differences related to field. The fieldindependent cognitive style is ignored in such cases.
Paeth, ca a likert scaling of student value statements, field independence field dependence, and experimentally induced change dissertation abstracts international 1973 34 2288b 2289b doctoral dissertation, oregon state university, 1973university microfilms no. Field dependence field dependence, cognitive style, gender, career choice, geft, ambiverts, science and arts. Field dependencefield independence cognitive style, gender. Is field dependence or independence a predictor of efl. The effect of gender on field dependenceindependence is so small that this factor is practically insignificant. Field dependent learners often work well in teams as they tend to be better at interpersonal relationships. In the classroom activities such as extensive reading and writing, which learners can carry out alone, are useful for fieldindependent learners. Statements 1, 3, 4, 7, and 10, above indicate field independent characteristics. However, the findings revealed no significant relationship between cloze test performance and any of other variables. Field independence appears to result in a greater development of cognitive restructuring skills. Fieldindependence who are field independent learners.
Graduate thesis or dissertation a likert scaling of student value statements, field independencefield dependence. Fielddependent learners often work well in teams as they tend to be better at interpersonal relationships. To assess the instructional effect of coding black and white and color and field dependencefield independence, 119 university students were assigned to randomly ordered treatment groups, received their respective instruction and two criterion. Be able to recognize the correlates of field independence and field dependence. The effect of gender on field dependence independence is so small that this factor is practically insignificant. Other articles where field independence is discussed.
Relationship between field dependence field independence. Fielddependence, extraversion, eysenck and autarky. Learning style is how a person approachesproblems, addresses issues, asksquestions, and interacts with theteacher and peers. For example, learners can discuss what they know about a topic, predict content, or look at and listen to related material. Summerville 1999 referred to field dimensions of independence and field dependence as a global versus an articulated style that reflects the degree to which an individuals processing of information is affected by the contextual field p. The fd individual has difficulty in studying a particular item when it occurs within a field of other items. Two distinct cognitive styles exist from the perspective of cognition.
498 34 1331 1071 25 26 1104 106 492 770 907 115 741 662 1379 1525 417 1079 1103 1006 1527 36 1460 426 1056 709 591 117 88 1605 159 883 49 353 396 1476 623 736 1345 75 1121